In this essay from Finding the Mother Tree, UBC Professor Suzanne Simard reflects on parenting, climate change, and the networks at the heart of the forest.
This is key to understanding how we build the Internet, despite what it turned into, and why we need to decentralize all systems over the coming decade. It also crystallizes Regenerative Design as the basis of how we start any building using technology by allowing sensors to collect data for analysis. Insights gained from that data are used to manage assets, resources and services efficiently; in return, that data is used to improve the operations of our ReGen Villages in realtime.
I WIPED MY glasses and glanced nervously through the trees. Fresh bear prints were climbing from the creek toward the hillcrest. I fumbled through the back of my vest and found my bear spray. I pulled off the safety, just in case.
It was April 2006, and my marriage was fraying. I had traveled four hours from the University of British Columbia, where I’d just wrapped up my teaching term, to this forest near Kamloops, British Columbia, a dry patch of interior Douglas fir. I was looking for a site for one of my new graduate students, Kevin, to make a map of the mycorrhizal fungal network. (Mycorrhizal fungi form an obligate symbiosis with tree roots, and the fungi trade nutrients and water they gather from soil in exchange for some of the tree’s photosynthate; these fungi can even link trees together in an interconnecting web.) The forest was still many hours from Nelson, where I’d just moved with my husband, Don, and two daughters, Hannah and Nava, 8 and 6 years old, and I wanted to get home to them by midnight. I was working at the university in Vancouver on weekdays, then returning home to Nelson every weekend. The commute from Vancouver to Nelson was nine hours as the crow flies, and this forest near Kamloops was about halfway between. The long commute was exhausting, but it meant I could continue my research and teaching at the university while also, hopefully, saving my marriage
The separation from my daughters during the week, though, was tearing me apart; I was spending more time away from them than I ever imagined. I had always been by their side, but now we were separated for days on end, just at a time when they were starting a new life, meeting new friends, and attending a different school—when they needed me the most.
But I was excited too, because this was a multi-aged forest, with trees hundreds of years old towering over a flock of saplings and seedlings. This complex forest could provide clues about the relationships between the old parents and their young.
AT THE FIRST elder tree, about 20 yards in, mosquitoes biting my forehead, my knees sore on twigs, I sliced into the forest floor with my trowel. I felt the tip hit something soft, like a cooked potato. It was a truffle the size of a confectionary in a box of chocolates, and it was resting smack between the humus layer and mineral horizon. I scraped away the soil particles and found a beard of black fungal strands running from one end of the truffle to the old tree’s roots. I followed another pulpy skein in the other direction, and it led me to a cluster of root tips that looked like the rosette of white flowers on a pussytoe plant. The fine, soft brush I’d borrowed from Hannah’s paint set was perfect for sweeping them clean. One root tip was especially welcoming, and I gently tugged it, like pulling a stray thread in a hem. A fir seedling a hand’s length away shuddered slightly. I pulled again, harder, and the seedling leaned back in resistance. I looked at my old tree, then at the little seedling in the shadows. The fungus was linking the old tree and the young seedling.
A shock of nearby boughs shivered, and a yellow butterfly flittered across the meadow. The wind shifted. I looked over at the grasses hemming the fold of trees, blades tingling. My eyes were attuned to edges where consortiums of bears and coyotes and birds linger and banter, but there was no movement.
I tracked another root from the elder and found another truffle, and another. I raised each to my nose and breathed in its musty, earthy smell of spores and mushroom and birth. I traced the black pulpy whiskers from each truffle to the riggings of roots of seedlings of all ages, and saplings too. With each unearthing, the framework unfolded—this old tree was connected to every one of the younger trees regenerated around it. Later, Kevin would return to this patch and sequence the DNA of almost every Rhizopogon truffle and tree—and find that most of the trees were linked together by the Rhizopogon mycelium, and that the biggest, oldest trees were connected to almost all of the younger ones in their neighborhood. One tree was linked to 47 others, some of them 20 yards away by Rhizopogon alone. We published these findings in 2010, followed by further details in two more papers. If we’d been able to map how the other 60 fungal species connected the firs, we surely would have found the weave much thicker, the layers deeper, the stitching even more intricate.
A squirrel’s midden of seeds was piled against a moist log, so I looked up to the tree crowns for traces of the previous year’s cones. Douglas fir makes cones sporadically and in synchrony with the shifts in climate over clusters of years. The seeds are dispersed in summer from yawning cones by wind or gravity, or squirrels or birds, and they germinate in the warm beds of minerals and char and partially decomposed forest floor. Burned mixed seedbeds are especially delicious for germination.
Through the corset of branches, I saw a hawk circle overhead, and I felt slightly uneasy. But the breeze lulled me, and I continued my work, using the finest tip of my Swiss Army knife to excavate a germinant no bigger than a daddy longlegs. I pulled on the collar of the exposed stem, and a radical—one of the tiny primordial roots—slid out of the old-blood humus. This courageous root was as vulnerable as a growing bone, and it survived by emitting biochemical signals to the fungal network hidden in the earth’s mineral grains, its long threads joined to the talons of the giant trees. The mycelium of the old tree branched and signaled in response, coaxing the virgin roots to soften and grow in a herringbone and prepare for the ultimate union with it.
Squatting, I peered at the radical through my hand lens and fumbled to split open the fragile root with my dirt-caked fingernails, to steal a glimpse of the fungal mycelium that might have succeeded in encasing the cortical cells. My nails were so blunt! I twisted around to let the sun pour on my hands, and I scoured the ragged root for signs of tallow between the cells. On invasion, the fungus envelops the root cells, forming a latticework—a Hartig net—the color of beeswax or seawater or rose petals. The fungus delivers nutrients, supplied by the vast mycelium of the old trees, to the seedling through this Hartig net. The seedling in return provides the fungus with its tiny but essential sum of photosynthetic carbon.
The roots of these little seedlings had been laid down well before I’d plucked them from their foundation. The old trees, rich in living, had shipped the germinants waterborne parcels of carbon and nitrogen, subsidizing the emerging radicals and cotyledons—primordial leaves—with energy and nitrogen and water. The cost of supplying the germinants was imperceptible to the elders because of their wealth—they had plenty. The trees spoke of patience, of the slow but continuous way old and young share and endure and keep on. Just as the steadiness of my girls steadied me, and I told myself I was strong enough to endure this season of separation. Besides, I’d have a sabbatical in a year, and I could make their lunches again, drumsticks and sliced cucumber and oranges cut into smiles, and I could show them how to build go-carts and plant flowers, and Nava and I could read together more, alternating turns through pages of Mercy Watson to the Rescue. But until that magical year, I’d spirit across the mountains each weekend to reabsorb their lives, my motherhood like time-lapse photography.
Once the Hartig net was firmly embedded in the radical of the new sprouts, and the old trees were dispatching sustenance, making up for the paltry rates of photosynthesis by the tiny new needles, the fungus could then grow new hyphal threads to explore the soil for water and nutrients. As the miniature crowns of the seedlings spawned new needles, they would feed the mycelium with their own photosynthetic sugars, so the fungus could travel to even more distant pores. Once on solid footing, life running as smoothly as a stock market exchange, the growing root could then support a fungal mantle—a coating—as though donning a jacket of mycelium, from which even more fledgling hyphae could grow into the soil. The thicker the mantle and the greater the number of fungal threads the root could feed, the more extensively the mycelium could laminate the soil minerals, and the more nutrients it could acquire from the grains and transport back to the root in trade. Root begets fungus begets root begets fungus. The partners keeping a positive feedback loop until a tree is made and a cubic foot of soil is packed with a hundred miles of mycelium. A web of life like our own cardiovascular system of arteries, veins, and capillaries. I wound two of my upended seedlings into my hair and started back up the slope.
I swept the bear spray out of my vest, peering toward a saskatoon bush. Pulling back a branch, its leaves rustling, I sighed in relief. There was only a stump, its charred bark as black as fur. Oh, boy, I thought. I must be tired from the early morning drive from the coast.
I continued through the trees, ducking under the crowns of thick-barked elders, striding through grassy gaps sprinkled with seedlings, swimming through thickets of spindly saplings, the data of my graduate students churning through my mind as if in an adding machine. These young trees got their start in the shadow of the old by linking into their vast mycelium and receiving subsidies until they could build enough needles and roots to make it on their own. The Douglas fir seeds that another of my graduate students, François, had sown around mature trees had a greater survival rate where he’d allowed them to link into old-tree fungal networks than where he’d isolated them in bags with pores allowing only molecules of water to filter through.
The seedlings in this forest were regenerating in the network of the old trees.
Resting on a stump, I took a long drink of water and noticed a cluster of seedlings no bigger than roofing nails. A belowground network could explain why seedlings could survive for years, even decades, in the shadows. These old-growth forests were able to self-regenerate because the parents helped the young get on their own two feet. Eventually, the young ones would take over the tree line and reach out to others requiring a boost.
With the sun straight overhead, I double-checked the time on my BlackBerry. I marveled at this little machine, how the internet made me feel so connected to the world.
This forest was like the internet too. But instead of computers linked by wires or radio waves, these trees were connected by mycorrhizal fungi. The forest seemed like a system of centers and satellites, where the old trees were the biggest communication hubs and the smaller ones the less busy nodes, with messages transmitting back and forth through the fungal links. Back in 1997, when my article showing carbon was transmitted between Douglas fir and paper birch through the mycorrhizal network had been published in Nature, the journal had called it the “wood-wide web.” This was turning out to be much more prescient than I’d imagined. All I knew back then was that carbon moved back and forth between the tree species through a simple weave of mycorrhizas. This forest, though, was showing me a fuller story. The old and young trees were hubs and nodes, interconnected by mycorrhizal fungi in a complex pattern that fueled the regeneration of the entire forest.
Wasps swarmed from a hole beside woody debris. Stung, I ran up the slope, as steep as an escalator, my vest heavy as a flak jacket, and flopped down at the crest, pressing my water bottle against a welt. The big old trees on this knoll were spaced farther apart, and the saplings were fewer and farther between. Limited by drought. The thimbleberries and huckleberries had disappeared, replaced by the bunched long leaves of pine grass, the bonnets of silky lupines, and the occasional soapberry shrub. The lupine and soapberry were nitrogen fixers, adding nitrogen to this slow-growing stand.
With my increment borer I cored a handful of ancients on the knoll. The oldest was 302 years old, the youngest 227. The largest, oldest ones were the elders of the forest. Their thick bark was scarred by flames, more pronounced than the trees in the wetter area below, because it was hotter and drier here, a magnet for lightning. This explained the wide range of ages. I checked my phone again. Two o’clock. In an hour, Don would be picking Hannah and Nava up from school.
I scraped the soil with my trowel. Just like the old trees near the creek, those on this crest were decorated with truffles and tubercules—clusters of mycorrhizal roots covered in a fungal rind—and golden fungal strands that ran from them like shooting stars. The trees and fungi here too were in an intimate web. Compared to the trees down below, there were even more connections where the soil was drier and the trees more stressed. This made sense! Here on the crest, the trees invested more in mycorrhizal fungi because they needed more from them in return.
I leaned against the oldest tree, at least 75 feet tall with branches like the ribs of a whale. Seedlings were germinating in a crescent along the northern drip line of the tree, their needles stretched like spider legs, and I excavated one with my knife. Fungal threads streamed off the end of its roots, and I felt intoxicated, already forgetting the wasp sting. I pressed the seedling and its woolen mycorrhizas between the pages of my notebook so I could look more closely at home. But I already knew; these little seedlings were linked into the network of the old trees, receiving enough water to get them through the driest days of summer. My students and I had already learned that the deep-rooted trees brought water up to the soil surface at night by hydraulic lift and shared it with shallow-rooted plants, helping the archipelago stay whole during prolonged drought.
Without such an attachment, death of a seedling in the hot August days can be nearly immediate, needles turning red and the collars of their stems wounded with burns, leaving not a trace by snowfall. For these young recruits, small resource gains in moments of vulnerability make the difference between life and death, two sides of the dealer’s card. But once their roots and mycorrhizas reach the labyrinth of russet pores, where water clings in films to soil particles, they ratchet up their game and grow a foundation.
I WALKED FROM the northern crescent of seedlings back to the old tree, the ground directly underneath its canopy bare even of grass. Not a seedling grew here. Its crown was so dense that it intercepted most of the precipitation and sun, and its roots were so thick that they took up most of the nutrients and water. But François would later find there was a sweet spot, a doughnut, at the drip line, the fringe of the crown, where the water dripped off the outermost needles and some seedlings flourished. Not too close to be starved by the needs of the old tree, and not too far away for the grasses in the intervening meadows to rob them of what they required.
I ducked under the opposite edge of the old tree’s crown—facing south, where the sun beat down—and gazed down the slope rolling into scree. It was so hot and dry on this side that not even a network could save a seedling from burning up. In the extremes—such as a desert—even the fungus could fail to bring life to a tree. An old log lay on the angle of repose, poised to roll over broken stones, and chunks of heartwood were newly exposed, beetles and ants flowing in lines with white fungi in their clutches. Claw marks. Bear, I thought, from at least a few days before. Douglas fir seedlings cascaded off the north side of the log, where there was a sliver of shade along its length, and they spilled onto the forest floor. The scrap of advantage from the shade meant a little less water lost, a slightly thicker film coating the soil pores, the difference between survival or not. I wondered if the white fans of mycelium were linked to the old tree and helped keep the wood moist. These seedlings were alive, I figured, only because the fungi were importing water from somewhere.
Skin burning, I returned to the shade and checked the wasp sting. I should show my girls how to make a poultice of baking soda. I sat and leaned back against the old tree nurturing that crescent of seedlings through the mycorrhizal network, the needles of the young quivering in the afternoon air.
The old trees were the mothers of the forest.
The hubs were Mother Trees.
Well, mother and father trees, since each Douglas fir tree has male pollen cones and female seed cones.
But … it felt like mothering to me. With the elders tending to the young. Yes, that’s it. Mother Trees. Mother Trees connect the forest.
This Mother Tree was the central hub that the saplings and seedlings nested around, with threads of different fungal species, of different colors and weights, linking them, layer upon layer, in a strong, complex web. I pulled out a pencil and notebook. I made a map: Mother Trees, saplings, seedlings. Lines sketched between them. Emerging from my drawing was a pattern like a neural network, like the neurons in our brains, with some nodes more highly linked than others.
If the mycorrhizal network is a facsimile of a neural network, the molecules moving among trees were like neurotransmitters. The signals between the trees could be as sharp as the electrochemical impulses between neurons, the brain chemistry that allows us to think and communicate. Is it possible that the trees are as perceptive of their neighbors as we are of our own thoughts and moods? Even more, are the social interactions between trees as influential on their shared reality as that of two people engaged in conversation? Can trees discern as quickly as we can?
How similar could the mycorrhizal network really be to a neural network? Sure, the pattern of the network and the molecules transmitting from node to node through the links might be similar. But what about the existence of the synapse; isn’t that crucial to signaling in a neural network?
Could information be transmitted across synapses in mycorrhizal networks, the same way it happens in our brains? Amino acids, water, hormones, defense signals, allelochemicals (poisons), and other metabolites were already known to cross the synapse between the fungal and plant membranes. Any molecules arriving by way of the mycorrhizal network from another tree might also be transmitted through the synapse.
Chemicals are released into these synapses, and the information must then be transported along an electrochemical source-sink gradient from fungal-root tip to fungal-root tip, similar to the workings of a nervous system. The same basic processes, it seemed to me, were occurring in the mycorrhizal fungal network as in our neural networks. Giving us that flash of brilliance when we solve a problem or make an important decision or align our relationships. Maybe from both networks emerge connection, communication, and cohesion.
It was already accepted widely that plants use their neural-like physiology to perceive their environment. Their leaves, stems, and roots sense and comprehend their surroundings, then alter their physiology—their growth, ability to forage for nutrients, photosynthetic rates, and closure rates of stomata for saving water. The fungal hyphae, too, perceive their environment and alter their architecture and physiology. Like parents and children, my girls and Don and me, adapting to change, aligning to learn new things, figuring out how to endure. I’d be home tonight. Mothering.
The Latin verb intelligere means to comprehend or perceive. Intelligence.
The mycorrhizal networks could have the signature of intelligence. At the hub of the neural network in the forest were the Mother Trees, as central to the lives of the smaller trees as I was to Hannah and Nava’s well-being.
IT WAS GETTING on, so I got up, sorry to leave the bark warm against my back. But I was breathless with elation, high on my thoughts, and I felt a kinship with the Mother Trees, grateful for accepting me and giving me these insights. I walked to the top of the knoll, remembering a small route out to the main haul road, and I followed a deer trail heading roughly in its direction.
My little trail joined another, like a frayed thread joining a rope. I knew the networks were complex, with thick cords like freeways amid a gauze of fine hyphae that behaved like secondary routes. The thick cords themselves consisted of many simple hyphae that had twined together, forming an outer rind around a space. Information chemicals could travel through these cords like water through a pipeline.
The main trail widened, and after a few more curves, the small road would lie ahead. The thick pipelines of fungal species like Rhizopogon were designed for long-distance communication, and the fine mycelial fans of fungal species like Wilcoxina must be adept at rapid response. Able to transmit chemicals swiftly to trigger fast growth and change.
The thick, complex strands running out from the Mother Trees must be capable of efficient, high-volume transfer to the regenerating seedlings. The finer-spreading mycelia must help the new germinants modify to accommodate pressing, rapid needs, such as how to find a new pool of water on a particularly hot day. Pulsing, active, adaptive in providing for the growing plants, like fluid intelligence.
A grant I was working on with my colleague Dan would eventually show us that the complex mycorrhizal network unraveled into chaos with clear-cutting. With the Mother Trees gone, a forest would lose its gravitas. But within a few years, as seedlings grew into saplings, the new forest would slowly reorganize into another network. Without the pull of the Mother Trees, though, the new forest network might never be the same. Especially with widespread clear-cutting and climate change. The carbon in the trees, and the other half in the soil and mycelium and roots, might vaporize into thin air, compounding climate change. Then what?
Wasn’t this the most important question of our lives?
I reached a colossal tree, a rampart, her branches thick right to the ground and as big as trees themselves. Her large size and old age were magnificent compared to her neighbors. She looked like the mother of all Mother Trees. What foresters call a “wolf tree”—far older, bigger, and with a much wider crown than the others, a lone survivor of previous calamities. She had lived through centuries of ground fires that others had—at one time or another—succumbed to. I waded through squalls of seedlings to get to the fringe of her crown and picked up a cone perhaps clipped by a squirrel, its bracts dusted in white spores. Her life had started when the Secwepemc people cared for this land, long before the Europeans came, when the Native people regularly lit fires to create habitat for game, or to stimulate growth of valuable native plants, or to clear routes for trading with neighboring nations, and they’d kept the fuels low so the flames were never intense enough to have burned off her thick bark completely. I was sure if I cored her, her rings would be calloused with char every twenty years or so, like the stripes of a zebra. I was struck by her endurance, her rhythm that spanned centuries. It was a matter of survival, not a choice, not an indulgence. Light glanced off her bark, incandescent, the sun dropping.
I returned to the trail, telling myself to publish my thoughts on Mother Trees as soon as I could, and I rounded the last corner before the road.
On the edge of the path, only 2 yards away, were two cubs the size of teddy bears, staring through the purple larkspurs and pink lady-slipper orchids. One was brown, the other black, and they looked at me politely. Behind them wearing a black fur coat was their mama. She growled, and they darted into the huckleberries and birches, leaving me stunned. Alone, untouched.
I hurried onto the little road and raced to the main haul-way, wondering if they’d been with me all day.
Edited by Jean-Marc La Flamme
Excerpted from FINDING THE MOTHER TREE by Suzanne Simard. Copyright © 2021 by Suzanne Simard. Excerpted by permission of Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Penguin Random House LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.